You have your innocent protagonist who gets caught up in the popularity contest of high school and we come to find out she is a lot more flawed than we originally suspected.
You have your gay best friend and the outcast best friend who desperately want to take down the Plastics for mysterious reasons you only find out about towards the end.
You have your hot guy who the protagonist is chasing throughout the course of the film.
You have your three evil popular girls who will do whatever it takes to stay popular. Within this group, you have...
- The leader
- The right hand/gossip
- The idiot who goes along with whatever the leader comes up with
This particular movie is unique because the protagonist goes from being an innocent home school kid to an unsuspecting high school kid and then is convinced that posing as one of the evil popular girls will give her lots of gossip to share with her new outcast friends.
I'll not tell you much more about how this goes, but suffice it to say that this is a very well done movie. The characters are flawed, the popular girls are evil but subtle, people react to the situations they get themselves into in very realistic ways, the comedy is hilarious but again, subtle, and it is just very well done.
Note: While it's true that Lindsay Lohan plays our darling innocent protagonist, keep in mind that this is before her life took a nosedive. She is the same sweet redhead you remember from The Parent Trap and Freaky Friday. I think this movie was finished just before she dyed her hair blonde and started turning into a drunk druggie.
A couple other characters you may recognize... Tina Fey plays the math teacher. Rachel McAdams plays the leader of the popular girls. Yes... Your favorite amnesiac from The Vow plays an absolutely terrible person. And Amanda Seyfried plays our lovable idiot.
For some reason, this movie just works. The chemistry between the characters is great, and that is why I was wary of watching the direct-to-TV sequel. Mean Girls 2. Why make a sequel? There weren't really any loose ends. Worse! Why make a sequel that has only one character carried over into it, that being the principal. Honestly, this sequel is like a Disney-fied wannabe version. When I saw it, I kept thinking of High School Musical, except something occurred to me. Sharpay was a better villain than this new evil girl. How does that happen? No, forget Disney-fied wannabe version, it was a wannabe of a Disney-fied wannabe version. That's how much they messed this thing up!
Let's start with our time frame. While the first film showcased an entire year, thereby giving our main character plenty of time to develop her character and infiltrate the popular girls, the second film did not take an entire year. Instead, it seems to have only taken a few weeks or a month at most. Not nearly enough time for all the required character development and certainly not enough time to turn the entire school's social structure upside down.
Next, we have our protagonist. Cady (LiLo) was believable in what she did. As an impressionable home school student with no real high school experience, it's easy to believe that she might get caught up in the whirlwind of the popular girls. Our protagonist from the sequel was supposedly a road worn, toughened girl who -after going through sixteen different schools- knew how to behave herself and wasn't about to get caught up in the drama. Or so she narrated. She is inconsistent at best, completely annoying at worst and it is very difficult to relate to her.
Now for our mean girls. In both films they are called the Plastics, but in the first film they are done well. They are subtle. There is no way anything they do wrong can really be traced back to them - they just don't leave much proof. People know they're evil, but they're also beautiful, they dress revealingly and... Well, it's easy to see why they never lack boyfriends. They are popular, the kind of girls who will smile and wave prettily from afar while whispering to each other about what a loser you are.
Allow me to explain something to you about the differences between mean boys and mean girls...
Mean boys will get physical. They'll physically fight and when they're done, they might still hate each other, or they might end up being friends. Who knows? Mean girls will be mentally abusive. They'll talk behind your back, start rumors, and prey on insecurities, causing forms of low self esteem that span lifetimes. In many ways, this is a much dirtier way to fight than the way boys do.
The Plastics in the sequel are not nearly so subtle. They resort to pulling pranks. Harmful pranks, yes, but they are so easily traceable. Unless someone has a tape recorder, there is no proof that the original Plastics did/said whatever it is they did/said. All these new Plastics need to rat them out for their stupidity is a video camera. And everyone has video cameras nowadays. Also, their style is ridiculously preppy with floral patterns and hair bows. If the originals were Barbie dolls, the new ones are American Girl dolls. This makes the out-of-place make out scenes even more ill-fitting. I felt like even though they were all teenagers, I was watching middle school kids make out, which quite frankly, I never ever needed to see.
Those are my main problems in comparing these movies. You also have the stupid stuff, like the shop teacher informing everyone that they'll need a 4.5 GPA to even be considered for this super fancy scholarship (the highest GPA you can get is 4.0...), the richest girl in school being terrorized for no apparent reason except the second richest doesn't like her, and the principal, who maintained an air of authority in the first film, was degraded to be a goofball in the second. Also, you have the basic Disney-channel movie formula wherein there's a contest and the main character either throws it or comes in second but is okay with it just to prove that winning isn't that important anyway.
There's also the apparent lack of a story arc in the sequel. In the first, you have the basic story arc wherein you are introduced to the characters, the main character goes through several crises, before everything comes to a climax and then calms down. In the second, you have the introduction and... Nothing. I suppose the football game was supposed to be the climax, but it didn't seem that climactic.
If you want to watch both these films, watch the second one first. Why? Because you should have something to look forward to in the first. Also... while the second one is probably only rated PG-13 because they said the B-word a couple of times, the first one is rated PG-13 for good reason. I personally wouldn 't put this movie on for anyone under the age of fifteen or sixteen... But that's just me. My advice is to completely skip the second movie, it's irrelevant to the first and doesn't add anything at all.
These movies are not owned by me.
-Kj